Prison Plant TV
  • Listen to Alex Jones
  • Scientists Rebut Claim That Man Causes Climate Change

    • Text size
    • Larger
    • Smaller

    Penny Starr
    CNSNews
    October 13, 2009

    As the world focused on President Barack Obama winning the Nobel Peace Prize on Friday, a small group of determined scientists gathered in a Senate office building to present evidence backing their claim that climate change is caused not by man but by nature, and that carbon dioxide is not a pollutant but the hope for a greener planet.

       
    fall of the republic

    John Kwapisz, organizer and moderator at the panel discussion, recalled Obama’s speech at the G20 summit in Pittsburgh, Pa., last month as a way of illustrating the dramatic tone used by those who embrace global warming as a dire and eminent threat.

    “That so many of us are here today is a recognition that the threat from climate change is serious, it is urgent, and it is growing,” Obama said on Sept. 22 at the summit. “Our generation’s response to this challenge will be judged by history, for if we fail to meet it — boldly, swiftly, and together – we risk consigning future generations to an irreversible catastrophe.”

    Read entire article

    • Social bookmarks
    • Social bookmarks
    • Email this article
    • Email this article
    • Print this page
    • Share on Twitter

    Comment Rules

    52 Responses to “Scientists Rebut Claim That Man Causes Climate Change”

    1. Paul23 Says:

      This is one part that i don’t understand

      It’s not Carbon Dioxide that is bad for you,

      It’s Carbon MONOXIDE….

      Why do people keep confusing the two…

      Spook45 Reply:

      Dumbing Down; Basicly people are STUPID. That is like the paper cos cutting down all of the disiduous forests and planting Conifers in thier place and calling it conservation. Conifers make better paper, but they rape the land and increase heat signature. Real trees put O2 back into the atmosphere, yet intead of figuring those things out and fixing them, they blame it on man and use it tax the f--- out of US.

      roaddog6 Reply:

      and any scientist that says its man made is not a scientist, but a shill being paid to say it.

      Michael the Gardener Reply:

      Chemtrails are also traping air pollution… wake up
      ………….and hemp is far beter than trees

      Gary Reply:

      Because they are IGNORANT of basic science. The “education” system has seen to it that we have become increasingly ignorant of the fundamentals of reality.

      Red Dawn 09 Reply:

      Only the politicians are pushing that global warming is man made. You had better have your things prepared for travel and have it ready for transport soon. Dont forget salt,magnisium fire starter,hatchet,hand saw,wood working tools,vitamins,water filter,portable burner,first aid kit with snake bite and bee sting kit,dehydrated food,emergency blankets,extra socks,sturdy boots for all,hunting knife,compass,rope,carabiner clips,heavy duty trash bags for keeping your things dry while fording rivers,galvanised screws,warm cloths,sugar,spices,weapon&ammo ALOT,tarps not tents,sleeping bags rated 20 below 0,bug repelent,razor blades,ace bandages,laminated maps, and alot im sure you have allready. Your life DOES depend on it so spare no expence on these things. Click my name for solid information on todays hottest topics. Movies,video’s,blog’s,text and when your just to full of info to continue, Games. Updated daily and newly awakened patriots welcome.

      Captain Wonderful Reply:

      Excellent, let us coordinate, Northwest mountains, Stevens Pass, bout 20 minutes west of Levinworth WA.

      Patrick Swayzee will be sorely missed, but looks like brother Charlie has entered the fray

      code 3%

      Blow the dust of yer CB….

      Gary Reply:

      Well, technically CO2 will indeed poison the human body. It is expelled from the body of all animals. It is plants that need CO2. So CO2 is truly a “life gas.” Think about a planet without plants.. Pretty horrifying, eh? Plants use CO2 like animals use oxygen. It’s a beautiful, natural symbiosis between plants and animals. Our waste gas is their boon and vice-versa. As long as CO2 isn’t allowed to displace the oxygen on our bodies – it’s harmless. Indeed, our bodies create CO2!

      But I do agree with the comments about the dumbing down. It is a fact. Americans are now barely above the level of idiots, sitting and drooling in front of their televisions. They know nothing that isn’t told them through “The Media.” It’s embarrassing.

      scott Reply:

      Yeah, but people are beginning to stir from their slumber I think.

      I am not amused Reply:

      Paul23:

      Those that say CO2 carbon monixide is a pollutant to the planet and is causing “global warming” are not confused. It is a more sinister agenda going on it is called lying. They are not confused they know exactly what they are doing and why it is called lying. If they get this passed; they will be able to tax you simply for farting or breathing.

      They are not confused they are lying and there is a significant difference.

      I was able to ascertain from the evidence out there that temperature fluctuations are primarily caused by sunspots aka solar flares. I think they know that also.

      They are just lying plain and simple. I have noticed there is big money and fame to be made in mass lying these days.

      Tragic.

      I am not amused Reply:

      I had an error in the above post I meant to say Carbon Dioxide not Monoxide. It is Dioxide that is the new terror to the earth.

      Sorry, it is ridiculous and would be comical if it were not so serious and tragic.

      Peopleforthepeople Reply:

      ‘Everything you know is a lie’ By: Lloyd Pye on Google Video. Everything you think you know is based on a lie. It’s time for peace, time for love and time to be one again.

    2. Martin Says:

      He said, “we risk consigning future generations to an irreversible catastrophe.” I wish he would say that about these wars he keeps expanding. I put up the article from yesterday with a poll on dailyfraud….I mean kos. I am amazed, this global warming thing really is like a religion. These people are very serious about the fraud they have swallowed. Once people bite on a hook, it is very difficult for them to let go because that would mean that they were wrong. Oh, and no they can’t be wrong because they consider themselves to be intellectuals. They really do believe that are part of some smarter group. I guess you can sorta say that about us truthers in that we believe that we are at the cusp of the truth. We are very different in that we have humbled ourselves by admitting that we were wrong and were seriously fooled. I guess not everyone can do that

      Gary Reply:

      Gospel.

    3. The Prince aka (Insert Statement) Says:

      I read all the comments on the main articles site…
      So, its not just use who are awake, aware and enlightened to the Real truth !!!

      Tally Ho !

    4. The Prince aka (Insert Statement) Says:

      I read all the comments on the main articles site…
      So, its not just us who are awake, aware and enlightened to the Real truth !!!

      Tally Ho !

    5. spiritsoup Says:

      What we truly risk is enslaving our childrens children into a taxation on there own breath. How absurd. When the founder of the Weather channel says it’s a taxation scam then maybe the sheep might listen, but NOOOOOOO they choose to believe the lies told to them by the Obamas of the world. Anyone can look at the temps since last year when the solar activity started to wane and see that what they are brow-beating us with is yet another boogie man just like terrorism. Yet, on rolls the cult of environmental personality. So what’s next are over weight people going to be taxed because they breath heavier then thin people? I think yes.

    6. anon Says:

      Polar bears are at record numbers. The truth is: the establishment is scared of life. They fear us. They fear life. So, they try to cut the gas of life, carbon dioxide, by 80%.

    7. WAKE UP LAST CHANGE CLOCK TICKING Says:

      No humans do not polute the ecosystem, it’s a lie (yeah right)
      Billions of cars, trucks, trains, boats, airplanes, millions of factories and industry, whole countries wide of Amazon rainforest chopped away every day (Indonesia, 70-80 percent of rainforest cut down in the last twenty years), we see massive chopping of trees worldwide, dumpings of chemicals and oil all over the globe, billions brush their teeth with toothpaste with flouride every single day, waste here waste there, the polution goes on and on, and then some stil think human acitivity does no causing global warming and the whole polution.
      Burning oil massively, buring gas massively, buring coal massively + cutting the plants and trees away massively all at the same time, means global warming (energy waste)
      Weather extremes, does not mean hot summers or cold winters, but days/weeks of extreme cold or extreme heat.
      When do those idiot scientists wake up ? It’s the same with 9/11 a lot of them just don’t see it.
      They cannot think logic anymore, totally indoctrinated and confused, thanks to tv and other indoctrinated power hungry politicians and tyrants.

      Johnny Canuck Reply:

      The sun is the controller of our weather, that is what the scientists are trying to tell you. CO2 is not to blame, in fact that is the gas plant life depends on. Their waste product is oxygen. We have a symbiotic relationship with the plant life on our beautiful world. Global warming is to be blamed on the sun. All the planets have warmed up, but in reality we could be entering an ice age. I agree though, that we’ve got to stop polluting our environment. We should be making paper from hemp, not trees (and clothes too). Oil man Al Gore sucks and is a complete fraud! The “Greenies” have been duped. Look all this s--- up! BTW, the Polar bears are doing fine!

      james Reply:

      Stop talking about trees…the majority of CO2 is utilized by oceanic plankton. The whole environmental movement has been distorted by globalist in an effort to keep the 3rd world living in the conditions they are currently experiencing.

      Many good-natured environmentalist think the answer to help save the rainforest while creating economic growth for these countries is Eco Tourism???? seriously what a load of bulls---

    8. UNSANE Says:

      HOW DO PEOPLE NOT REALIZE THAT OBAMA AND FRIENDS ARE f---ING LIARS? HOW??

      Unconquered Reply:

      (sigh…!) I feel your pain. I wonder that daily.

    9. Michael Says:

      Climate Depot posted my videos of this Lou Dobbs CNN Story.
      http://www.climatedepot.com/a/.....plan-Video

    10. Michael Says:

      One of the Cruelest Things They Have Ever Done to Us!

      I’m not going to tell you who they are, I’m going to let you figure that one out for your selves. What I am going to tell you is what they did.

      They took away your 7Th Amendment. Oh, you still have it, you just don’t know you do. Let me tell you what they did. They created the bar association, that’s to bar you from entering. Then they appointed the Judges who work with the bar association to keep you at bay.

      They also made you think you could not defend yourselves through advertising. You believed them and that’s how you lost your 7Th Amendment.

      Please re-learn how to use the 7th Amendment and use it.

      Here’s a link you may want to use to get an education.

      Red Beckman Seminar
      http://video.google.com/videop…..237547562#

    11. Mm79 Says:

      Save the plannet! Stop people from breathing…all problems solved…it’s the perfect solution for the NWO.

    12. Michael Says:

      Lou Dobbs: Al Gore, “Not Evil Just Wrong” Global Warming Debate Part 1 10/12/09
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2ujzfnC7cI

    13. Mike J Says:

      Does anyone know why my post of of quotes from the Green Agenda showing the fraud of man made global warming’ isn’t being published??

      Michael the Gardener Reply:

      maybe youtube took it

    14. Max Says:

      700 scientists report

      http://f1.grp.yahoofs.com/v1/M.....ntists.pdf

    15. Phenix Says:

      You all do realize that the two biggest US emissions of Co2 are man made. The third biggest emitter is a volcano. Volcanoes can cause climate change just as man made factories can cause climate change if they emit too much Co2.

      We are able to measure Co2 in parts per million and the #s are similar to 15 million years ago. At that time sea levels were 25 meters higher then they are today. The Earth was warmer and weather patterns were different. The only thing capable of releasing this amount of Co2 are man made sources.

      And you all are parroting oil and gas company lines from the 90s and early 00s.

      Gary Reply:

      CO2 does NOT cause climate change. A buildup of atmospheric CO2 FOLLOWS a rise in atmospheric temperature, it does not precede it or cause it. You are ignorant of the basic science.

      Chris Reply:

      What do people think of the fact that this guy here in this article, Fred Singer, was a consultant to various major corporations, including GE, Ford, GM, Exxon, Shell, Sun Oil, Lockheed Martin and IBM?

      Both sides are infiltrated, we have to keep our eyes open.

      http://www.therevolutionisnow.co.uk

    16. Gary Says:

      “…carbon dioxide is not a pollutant but the hope for a greener planet.”

      That’s a bit weak. It makes it sound like something new we just discovered, when, in fact, it’s been known forever that CO2 is essential to all life on earth.

    17. Ben Says:

      Heat depends on the heater. The Earth’s heater is the Sun.

    18. Wake up, America! Says:

      The sunspots do it.

      And by the way, the sun is shrinking!

      It gives off 500 million tons a second.

      Where does that energy go? A ball of energy eventually runs out of steam.

      The sun is headed towards vanishing into outer space one day.

    19. scott Says:

      Sorry that should be CO not CO3, I apologise for my stupidy, that would be carbon trioxide, lol

    20. Norman Nichols Says:

      Alex Jones is being incredibly dishonest in his proaganda war against the case for Global warming. It would be simple enough to clear things up. Have a series od debates between the scientists who out out this report and scientists who make the case for human caused global warming. This would be the intellectually honest thing to do. So have a debate between Fred Singer one of the authors of this report and Richard Ally professor of atmospheric physics from Penn State who is one of the worlds leading researchers on global warming. Of course I fully expect that Alex Jones-something who probably can’t do basic trignometry-to have this debate on his show. Heis true believere. Facts don’t matter. By the way, there is been lots of experiments on the effects of rising CO2 on plants. And the results are overwhelming that CO2 concentrations beyond a certian level are detrimental to plant and tree heallth.

      There is a lot of supprt in the Alex Jones show for the antiwarming point of view. All I can say is, that these people have not made a serious study of the evidence . The glaciers are melting. Scientist have a pretty good handle when the glaciers in the Rockies will completely melt.

      The pinhead Evangelical execessivley anti-goverment types who who post want no intrference in their rape and plunder of the environment. So have the debate on your show Alex. It would be real public service.

      BY the way the 9/11 truthers have on many ocasions been decisevely defeates in public debate this is why on shows such Democracy now they had to resort to verbal abuse and taliking over their opponent. A serious case can be made against certain policies of he US goerment. However you folks discredit yourself pushing the anti-global warming point of view and the 9/11 nonesense.

    21. Its just the sun Says:

      Look at the planets surrounding us. Their tempature levels are rising also. What does this tell us? Only that the sun is getting hotter. :)

    22. Norman Nichols Says:

      By the way,the comments here indicate an extreme level of scientific illiteracy. The scientific issue is the level of CO2 in the atmosphere. No sane scientist would ever be for ridding the atmosphere completetly of CO2. You bible thumping Evangelicals are incredibly stupid people. I write this as a social conservative and a Catholic. You guys are an embarrasment.

      Michael the Gardener Reply:

      God is of no religion THERE ALL LIEING TO YOU

    23. Norman Nichols Says:

      Fed Singer, the senior scientist of this report is has worked for many years for the automotive and petroleum industry. In others words, he is on the $$$$$$$$$ take from the indistries that produve enormous amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere.

      Tell. why are the critics of Global Warmong the only ones allowed to discuss the Global Warming issue on prisonplanet.com. This reeks of the worldview of a true believer where fcts contrary to the truebelievers point of view are never aired. It would be easy enough to have a debate between Richard Ally who can be seen many times and the Discovery Channel discussing the science of Global Warming. Why not Alex Jones.If you are so certain that Global Warming is junk science, you and Fred Singer should have no problem disposing of Professor Ally or Ricahrd Hanson senior atmospheric scientist for NASA in debate.

    24. Solutions Says:

      This only one small example of how dangerous and insane our current leaders are with their CO2 footprint tax plan AND OTHER ISSUES!!!!!!!

      THINK ABOUT WHAT I AM SAYING

    25. Solutions Says:

      THE ANSWER IS VERY SIMPLE AND OUR FOUNDERS CLEARLY UNDERSTOOD, THAT WE THE PEOPLE NEED TO BE PROTECTED FROM THE WHIMS OF INSANE AGENDAS AND THIS IS WHY THEY CREATED OUR CONSTITUTION & BILL OF RIGHTS.

    26. Captain Wonderful Says:

      Norman, have you ever heard the science of anti global warming entertained on the Discovery Channel??

      Your hypocrisy is showing…..

      I bet you just fell in love with Al Gores’ “An Inconvenient Truth(sic)”

      Give Gaia a squeeze for me,

      Evangelical Bible Thumper

      ps. are you just a terrible speller or are your emotions tripping up your fingers?

    27. djt Says:

      The “cure” according to the believers of man made global warming is to create a system that serves the interests of the same people that continuously try to control the distribution of wealth. Their sole intent is to prohibit any nation from being independent as that is a threat to their system.

      Cap and Trade = Central control over the distribution of economic activity.

      It seems incredibly coincidental that a “problem” like the charade of man made global warming plays into their hand so perfectly. It is way to convienant.

    28. Knock Knock No One's left Says:

      OBAMA is worthless to us!
      The Congress is worthless to us!
      The News Media is worthless to us!
      The Police are worthless to us!
      Our money is now worthless to us!

      What has America left to offer us, that is worth something?
      No jobs.
      No land.
      No housing.
      No healthcare.
      No transportation.
      No real religious support.
      No trust in all politicians to do right.
      No need to list more negative truths now.

      People, and police, too – look at what you have today. Will you still have it to leave for your kids to enjoy? Forget what is happening to you now, when you are dust, what will be happening to them?

      This World is nothing more than a failed experiment and we were the cause of it’s failure. All we had to do was share the resources that were here on the planet…for everyone to have! GET IT RICH FOLKS! You bastards were suppose to share it!

      So now, your money and metals are worthless. Food and water will be the only things to barter. See what other 3rd World countries do! Turn the lights off when you leave…..

    29. Michael the Gardener Says:

      You are the Carbon they speak off

    30. Norman Nichols Says:

      Captain Wonderfull

      I never saw the Al Gore movie. I despise Al Gore. Al Gore is completely irrelevant to the scientific case for Global Warming. Here is the difference. It is true that the Discovery Channel gives very little air time to the critcs of Global Warming. However they are not kept off for ideological reasons. They are kept off because the preponderance of scientific evidence and theory is massively against he critics of Global warming. Speaking for myself, I would very much like to see a debate between Fred Singer the senior author of the report and Atmospheric scientist Richard Ally on the Discovery Channel.

      Supporters of the view that global warming is anthropogenic in origin are kept off the Alex Jones show due ideological reasons-reasons that have 0 to do with serious science.

      How would you know or Alex Jones know what the truth is considering that you have no intetest in finding out what the truth is? You accept “scientic” truths that only fit into your nutty bible-thumping pinhead Evamglical world view. Scientcehas a much higher standard of truth.

      So, if you and Alex Jones are so confident of the truth of this scientific report put out by Scientists who are on the $$$$$$ take from Big Auto and Big Peteroleum ,and if it so obvious that the case for Global Warming is Junk Science, have a debate on the Alex Jones between two atmospheric scientists with opposing points of on Global Warming? This is the normal way the the truth is established truth is arrived. Just as it was arrived at on the 9/11 isue. I heard quite a few debates on this on the 9/11 truthers revealed themselves as a bunch clowns. Jason Bermas made a fool of himself on Democracy now. He is basically a bold face liar.

      We both know why Alex Jones wont have a debate about global warming on his Show. Alex Jones knows why also. Let’s see just how good Alex Jones debating skills.

      Alex Jones-although I agree with him on quite a few issues- is ultimately an enthusiast for the raping and plundering of America’s precious environment and biodiversity. He is also a supporteedrvery levels of nonm-white LEGAL IMMIGRANT scab labor. He was born into the ultra-reactionary cesspoool of Teas political culure:rape and plunder the environment and use LEGAL IMMIGRATION to transfer wealth from the working class to the superrich.

    31. Dooley Womack Says:

      We know what makes Alex Jones tick:twelve hot dogs with a load of mustard followed by loud bellowing of half vetted “facts” through a megaphone and teenaged acolytes wearing ridiculous garish T-shirts.The main thing learned is that a poor diet leads to lesser brain function.Used to admire Jones but sadly have realized that he’s a buffon and a quasi- intellectual.

    32. bohemiangrooves Says:

      i don’t know. i mean i’m a greenie, does that mean i am sheep because i think the science for global warming outweighs the science that states warming is a hoax, that man has no influence? i read everything i can get my hands on with this subject, including all the articles posted on this site that seemingly claim to gives irrefutable proof that global warming is a hoax. to be honest they are no more convincing that listening to an obama speech about it. and frankly, the fact that global warming hoax articles speak in concert with what bush officials and big oil companies are pushing makes me less inclined to believe them…and no, starting the weather channel DOES NOT make you an expert on climate change, anymore that starting a news channel makes rupert murdoch an expert on news. And i dont understand this connection i keep reading in comments about global warming = globalist tactic to tax us to death…there is no logic in this statement considering there are many ways one could approach dealing with co2 reduction (including pure corporate ways).

      I just dont get the readers here. Accusing the ‘rest of us’ as being gullible to lies and media distortions, yet not believing for once second that something they read on this site may be guilty of the same thing. If you are going to be cynical about stuff you read, then it has to include stuff on this site.

    33. ob Says:

      As the time goes on , people of america have everyday less and less freedom due to politics conducted by federal power. Also , as a consequence of the economic crisis , more and more of them have lost their job and home. But the crisis is not finished , and in near future the consequences could be catastrophic. Keep in mind that any change can not come from the federal government , but only the people , the only source of any future chagement. If a majority of them think a change is possible , so it can be. A way to preserve freedom , ideals , welfare of people is federalism must come to an end. People will have to make a choise , federalism versus freedom , ideals , welfare… . The first could lead to the establishment of a martial law. A state as texas is ready to cross the line , it could be an example for the others. People could put under pressure every state government in the aim to declare secession , the american constitution allow such a decision. Such an aim can’t be aimed without any precaution , as it is evident the federal power is not ready to yield or abdicate. Probably , this one will use force to submit people , but constitution give garantees on firearms. people can put up a fight against the oppressive federal power if a political issue according to the will of people can not be lead. People have to make his will respect , otherwise it will be an opressed people. Saying that federalism must come to an end mean it must be break down , it appears to be the only way to preserve people. America can be easily imagined without federalism and preserved.
      a j