A number of former senior national security officials are urging that the government embrace the move to strong encryption by tech companies — even if it means law enforcement will be unable to monitor some phone calls and text messages in terrorism and criminal investigations.
In so doing, they are taking a position at odds with their colleagues inside government, including FBI Director James B. Comey. U.S. officials argue that without access to such data, they may miss critical evidence of a terrorist plot or a murder or kidnapping.
But these former officials – previously at the National Security Agency, the CIA, the Pentagon and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence — are saying that there are larger, strategic national and economic security imperatives that outweigh law enforcement’s operational needs.
And they say that recent terrorist attacks in Paris and in San Bernardino, Calif., have not changed their views.